"Back In Pioneer Times" (Or, Semantics and the Past)

"I'm not a pilgrim! That was centuries ago!"

Jean Piaget explains, in his theory of cognitive development, that children are first able to distinguish the present from the past during the preoperational stage (ages 2-7 years old), and one past from another during the concrete operational stage (ages 7-11 years old). Knowledge of such development and learning theories are crucial for any museum education department, as well as for any adult who thinks that the past is just one amorphous blob and that "it's all the same anyway". Young museum visitors and students are able to discern various periods in time, and can associate with each differently - so help them out by being specific, and getting it right.

Much in the same way that "Upper Canada" and "Canada West" indicate certain geographical areas within specific periods of time, so to do the terms listed below. They are not all interchangeable, and should only really be used where appropriate. Oversimplifying for the sake of time or argument tends to rob historical groups of their accomplishments (for better or worse). It may also serve to confuse or mislead the person or group you're talking to - dangerous territory if you're dealing with students attempting to mentally map out a timeline.

Pioneer: A person who is among the first to explore or settle a new country or area
Settler: A person who settles in an area, typically one with no or few previous inhabitants.
Puritan: A member of a group of English Protestants of the late 16th and 17th centuries who regarded the Reformation of the Church of England under Elizabeth as incomplete and sought to simplify and regulate forms of worship.
Pilgrim: A member of a group of English Puritans fleeing religious persecution who sailed in the Mayflower (etc) and founded the colony of Plymouth, Massachusetts, in 1620.
Voyageur: (especially in Canada) A boatman employed by the fur companies in transporting goods and passengers to and from trading posts.
Colonial: Relating to the period of the British colonies in America before independence (1776).

To add to this, Victorians (1838-1901) for example, are not Puritans, Pilgrims, or Voyageurs, but can be pioneers or settlers depending on the place and the time. In Canada it's easy to visualize settlement as moving westward. Vancouver did not become an incorporated city until 1886 versus many Ontario towns which were founded in the early and mid-19th century, and by extension many Quebec and east coast settlements founded in the 17th and 18th centuries. So despite the 19th century being quite recent, many Victorians were the first to settle and establish many areas in the west.

As a former British colony, and as a member of the Commonwealth, we (Canadians) often denote specific periods of time in our history according to the reigning monarch. The Tudor period runs from 1485-1603; The Georgian period is often considered to span 1714-1830, and the Edwardian period from 1901-1914.

Sources
Simply Psychology 2012, "Jean Piaget"

Further Reading
TheFreeDictionary.com
The Commonwealth 2015, "Member countries"