Mr. Dickson's House

View of Galt, Ontario, including Scotch church and Mr. Dixon's House
Drawing by Alice E. Brown in 1857, Currently a part of the Archives of Ontario collection

Sources
Archives of Ontario, 2014 "View of Galt..."
James Young's 1880, Reminiscences of the early history of Galt
First United Church, Cambridge "About Us"

Further Reading
Lucille H. Campey's 2005, The Scottish Pioneers of Upper Canada, 1784-1855: Glengarry and Beyond

The Log Cabin Myth

Pioneers lived in log cabins... right? Well, it really depends on the period and the area in question. It also depends on your understanding of the definition of what constitutes a "log cabin". These excerpts from Hugh Morrison's Early American Architecture: From the First Colonial Settlements to the National Period help to explain:

Log House in Orillia Township, Ontario
1844 Picture by Titus Hibbert Ware

"By 'log cabin' we mean a dwelling built of round logs, laid horizontally on one another, with notched corners and protruding ends.... Spaces between logs, if any, are chinked with moss, clay, or oak chips.... the log cabin did not exist in any of the English colonies in the seventeenth century and was used very little throughout most of the eighteenth century. Neither did the Dutch use it in New Netherland, nor the French in Canada. It was a form of construction unknown in England, France, Holland, and southern Europe generally; it was likewise unknown to the American Indian.
...
It is tempting to believe that our early ancestors, gifted with ingenuity as well as courage, invented such an admirable solution to their urgent problem of quick and durable shelter. 
Apparently they did not. The English colonists did built blockhouses and prisons using logs hewn square and notched at the corners for either lapped or dovetail joints. This is indeed a superior type of construction, but it requires many tools and much skill and more time. The log cabin, if it had been known, would have supplanted the flimsy dugouts and cabins and wigwams the pioneer settlers actually built.
True log-cabin construction is thought to have been introduced into this country [the United States] by the Swedes when they settled Delaware in 1638.... In the eighteenth century, German settlers in Pennsylvania built large numbers of log houses, using both squared-log and round-log construction. Since most of the Germans entered the country by way of the Delaware valley, they must have acquired the technique from the Swedes...." (12-13)

Sources
Hugh Morrison's 1987, Early American Architecture
Harold Robert Shurtleff's 1939, The log cabin myth: a study of the early dwellings of the English colonists in North America

Further Reading
History News Network 2015, "Top 10 Myths About Thanksgiving"

A Castle Kilbride Christmas

Sometimes the holidays can bring throngs of tourists and visitors to museums and galleries. Sometimes people would rather stay home and relax, or go shopping for Boxing Day specials. Luckily for me the days immediately following Christmas were quiet ones for Castle Kilbride, and I could take my time and explore each highly decorated room at my leisure. Ahh Victorian Ontario.

Castle Kilbride was built in Baden in 1877 by Scottish immigrant and successful industrialist, James Livingston. The Italianate home was named after his birthplace of East Kilbride, just south of Glasgow. Livingston was best known for his empire in flax seed, which allowed him and two further generations of his family to live in Castle Kilbride in the lap of luxury.

"A tour through Castle Kilbride is a journey into the lavish Victorian Era. Castle Kilbride dominates the landscape with its clean Italianate design, towering Belvedere, rich and extravagant furnishings and most importantly, interior artistry the likes of which are unmatched in a private residence in all of Canada." (Castle Kilbride) 

Had I been able to take photos, I'm sure they would have turned out similarly to this example from a professional photographer. Unfortunately, due to the delicate nature of the items on display, and the many hand-painted elements of each space, photography is not permitted.

Castle Kilbride is one of those places that's right in your own backyard, one of those places that everyone's heard of, one of those places that few have been. It can be easier (and more exotic) to travel out of town to "see the sights", but we mustn't forget about the sights close to home. Be a tourist in your hometown! You'll be amazed at what you find. If you do live in Southern Ontario (or even if you don't), I would recommend a stop at Castle Kilbride. The people in Baden are friendly, and happy to show off the jewel of the township.

Sources
Castle Kilbride 2015, "History in the Making"
Waterloo Region Generations 2015, "James Livingston, MP"

Further Reading
Trust for Architectural Easements 2015, "Glossary of Architectural Terms"
Ontario Tourism Website

McDougall Cottage

Last month I had the opportunity to visit McDougall Cottage - a small but lovely historic home located along the shore of the Grand River at Grand Avenue South and Cedar Street.

"McDougall Cottage, ca.1858 granite and limestone labourer's dwelling, is located in downtown Cambridge in the historic factory district. Home for more than a century to two families of hardworking Scots, the McDougalls and the Bairds, this charming traditional cottage with its equally charming pocket-sized gardens, boasts the most spectacular hand-painted friezes (patterns along the top of walls or buildings) and trompe l'oeil ceilings (three dimensional illusions) that Ontario has to offer.
The Cottage serves as an interpretation centre, showcasing its unique interior landscape and presenting mini-exhibits on monthly themes." (Region of Waterloo)

During my visit I was able to see a temporary exhibit on quilting with a Scottish theme, as well as the beautiful friezes described in the quote above. There's a massive kitchen with a conservatory overlooking the gardens to the back of the house. There are apparently monthly teas held in this space which I'd love to attend. The staff are incredibly friendly and easy to talk to - a highly recommended little stop in Cambridge (right across from the Southworks Antique Market!). For more information on the cottage, its hours and calendar of events, see the links below.



Sources
Region of Waterloo, 2010 "McDougall Cottage"
Region of Waterloo, 2014 "Happenings at McDougall Cottage"
McDougall Cottage's Facebook Page
Cambridge Now, 2014 "McDougall Cottage"

Taxes and the Home in Upper Canada

While I was working as an interpreter within an historic home, I was absolutely shocked (on a number of occasions) to hear that visitors believed that taxes were something of a 20th century invention in Canada. Sometimes being an interpreter isn't about sharing new and exciting information with people, it's about trying to correct myths and misconceptions.

When it came to taxes and the home in Upper Canada, three considerations prevailed: the building material of the house, the number of storeys, and the number of fireplaces. In 1807, six categories were created to help determine who owed what to the government. Here they are in order of least to most amount of tax, regardless of the square footage of the house:

- Homes constructed of round logs
- Homes constructed of square timber, one storey
- Homes constructed of square timber, two storeys
- Framed (sawn wood) homes under two storeys
- Homes constructed of brick or stone of one storey with not more than two fireplaces
- Homes constructed of brick or stone of two storeys with not more than two fireplaces

Some good news for settlers in 1811 arrived when the government decided to no longer tax buildings made of round logs (presumably if you're living in a house made of round logs you can't afford to do much else let alone hand over cash to the taxman). Some more cunning families who wished to keep more of their money to themselves built homes that were one and a half storeys - 19th century houses of this height are still littered across Ontario today.

For the average home-owner in the 1830s however, the tax owed on a two storey brick home was about 5 shillings - roughly equivalent to a days' wages for a skilled labourer. It wasn't a prohibitive tax by any means, and the Scots were among the more prolific builders of homes in stone and brick:

"... among non-log houses, Scots used stone (17%) and brick (13%) most often, and frame (70%) the least, whereas about 85% of the Irish, American, German, English, and Ontario-born residents lived in frame houses." (Kalman, 170)

I have a particular fondness for one and a half storey stone houses. Duncan Ferguson house (1856), pictured here, is located at 71 Cowan Boulevard, Cambridge.

Sources
Harold Kalman's 1994, A History of Canadian Architecture, Vol. 1
Brian Coffey's 1985, "Factors Affecting the Use of Construction Materials in Early Ontario" in Ontario History

Further Reading
Historic Places "Duncan Ferguson Homestead"

"According to his fancy"

In his 1829 publication, Three Years in Canada: An Account of the Actual State of the Country in 1826-7-8, John MacTaggart dedicates a whopping three (of his 347) pages to informing his readers on the domestic architectural landscape in the colony. He begins his description by warning the reader that “the orders of architecture baffle all description: everyone builds his cottage or house according to his fancy….” (308) MacTaggart is clearly not a fan of the vernacular. That’s OK, neither was Vitruvius.

It is to MacTaggart’s credit that he is able to discern between these various fancies; how else would he be able to tell if he were walking up to the plain dwelling of an honest English farmer or the showy, yet charmless abode of a former American with at least one loose daughter? (309)

Here are the six most popular types of homes (and their corresponding occupants) as described by MacTaggart. An initial on-line search of extant period homes revealed a number of close matches to his brief descriptions. My search also revealed that MacTaggart might have some seriously crippling author-bias. 

The house of an "honest English farmer" (308-309)

The house of a “wealthy Lowland Scotchman” (309)

The house of a United Empire Loyalist from the United States (American) (309-310)

The house of a “wild pushing Highland-man” (310)

The house of a French Canadian (310-311)

The homes of the Dutch (311)

Sources
John MacTaggart's 1829, Three Years in Canada: An Account of the Actual State of the Country in 1826-7-8
Many older buildings reside in relative safety within historic "villages": Westfield Heritage Village, Upper Canada Village, and Black Creek Pioneer Village.

Further Reading
John Mac Taggart (b.1791, d. 1830) was a Scottish engineer and author; you can learn more about him (and his prejudices) online at the Dictionary of Canadian Biography.
Do some house hunting of your own: Ontario Architecture, Ontario Heritage Properties Database,